Transparent pricingWhat 50-Gallon Replacement Costs In Carrollton
$900 - $1,800 installed, depending on tank type, access, and code corrections
Typical 2026 pricing in this area runs $900 to $1,800 for a 50-gallon replacement, installed. Electric swaps with a standard tank sit near the low end. Gas units, power vent models, crawlspace installs, and jobs that need new venting or a shutoff valve push toward the top. We quote the job upfront, so the number you hear on the phone is the number you pay unless we find something hidden behind the tank.
The price covers removal, disposal, new connections, a new T&P valve, testing, and the manufacturer warranty on the tank. You are not paying twice for a repair that fails in six months, and you are not hauling a 150-pound tank to the curb.
Gas or electric•affects cost
Electric 50-gallon tanks are usually cheaper to buy and install. Gas units cost more because of the flex connector, leak test, and venting check. Power vent and direct vent models add more because of the blower and PVC venting.
Get a quote ↗Tank brand and warranty•affects cost
A standard Rheem or A. O. Smith 50-gallon tank sits at the base price. Longer-warranty models and premium brands like Bradford White cost more upfront but can last longer, which changes the cost per year of ownership.
Get a quote ↗Access and location•affects cost
A garage or wide closet swap is straightforward. Crawlspace installs, tight utility closets, and second-floor locations take longer and need more labor. We tell you the access surcharge before we start, not after.
Get a quote ↗Code corrections•affects cost
If the venting, gas line, drain pan, or T&P discharge pipe does not meet the Uniform Plumbing Code or International Plumbing Code, we correct it during the swap. That adds cost but keeps the install insurable and inspection-ready.
Get a quote ↗